How Rental Profit Moves When Prices Rise: Flat Rents and 3% Annual Cost Growth Cut NOI 11.9% in 10 Years; 1% Rent Growth Offsets It (¥100M, 12-Unit RC Model)
If rents stay flat while operating costs such as property tax, management, repairs and insurance rise 3% a year, NOI on a ¥100 million, 12-unit RC building falls from ¥5.76 million to ¥5.077 million in year 10, down 11.9%. Five rent-and-cost growth combinations are compared on DSCR, cumulative cash flow and year-10 value.

When prices and labor costs rise, a rental property's income and expenses move at different speeds. Many cost items tend to rise within a few years, while rents on many units cannot be changed until a lease renewal or a tenant turnover, so adjustments lag. In this model, a 12-unit reinforced-concrete (RC) building with ¥8 million in annual rent and ¥2.24 million in operating costs sees net operating income (NOI) fall from ¥5.76 million in year 1 to ¥5.077 million in year 10, a drop of 11.9%, if rents stay flat and operating costs rise 3% a year. Raising rents 1% a year nearly offsets that decline.
This article fixes one model property and compares ten years of cash flow under five combinations of rent and cost growth. The figures are a teaching simulation based on assumptions, not a real property or a forecast of future prices or rents. The aim is to show how to build the same table for your own property.
Model property and assumptions
Assume a 15-year-old RC rental building (12 units) purchased on these terms.
| Item | Amount / terms |
|---|---|
| Purchase price | ¥100 million |
| Annual rent (assuming full occupancy, no vacancy loss) | ¥8 million (gross yield 8.0%) |
| Operating costs (annual) | ¥2.24 million (28.0% of rent) |
| Breakdown | Property and city planning tax ¥600,000; management fee ¥400,000 (5% of rent); repairs and restoration ¥640,000 (8% of rent); common-area utilities and cleaning ¥400,000; insurance ¥200,000 |
| Year-1 NOI | ¥5.76 million (NOI yield 5.76%) |
| Loan | ¥80 million (20% equity), 2.5% annual rate, 25 years, level payments |
| Annual debt service | About ¥4.307 million |
Management and repair costs are often modeled as a share of rent, but for simplicity the total operating cost of ¥2.24 million is assumed to grow at a constant annual rate. The loan rate is fixed and payments do not change for ten years.
Five combinations of rent and cost growth
NOI in years 1, 5 and 10 under different growth rates for rent and operating costs:
| Case | Rent change (per year) | Operating cost change (per year) | Year-5 NOI | Year-10 NOI | Year-10 costs as share of rent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | Flat (0%) | +3% | ¥5.479 million | ¥5.077 million | 36.5% |
| B | +1% | +3% | ¥5.804 million | ¥5.827 million | 33.4% |
| C | +2% | +2% | ¥6.235 million | ¥6.884 million | 28.0% |
| D | −0.5% | +2% | ¥5.417 million | ¥4.970 million | 35.0% |
| E | +1% | +1% | ¥5.994 million | ¥6.300 million | 28.0% |
Case A has flat rents and 3% annual cost growth. Year-10 operating costs reach ¥2.923 million and NOI falls by ¥683,000 (11.9%). In Case B, raising rents 1% a year lifts year-10 rent to ¥8.749 million; the extra ¥749,000 roughly absorbs the ¥683,000 increase in costs. Because operating costs are under 30% of rent, a rent growth rate below the cost growth rate can still offset the increase.
In Case D, rents fall 0.5% a year while costs rise 2% a year, leaving year-10 NOI at ¥4.97 million (13.7% below year 1). Falling rents combined with rising costs erode income more than cost growth alone.
Debt service coverage (DSCR) and cumulative cash flow
Because loan payments are fixed, any decline in NOI flows straight through to cash flow after debt service. The table compares ten-year cumulative cash flow (NOI minus debt service) and year-10 DSCR (NOI ÷ annual debt service of ¥4.307 million).
| Case | Year-1 DSCR | Year-10 DSCR | 10-year cumulative cash flow | Year-10 NOI valued at 5.76% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 1.34 | 1.18 | About ¥11.25 million | About ¥88.14 million |
| B | 1.34 | 1.35 | About ¥14.95 million | About ¥101.16 million |
| C | 1.34 | 1.60 | About ¥20.0 million | About ¥119.52 million |
| D | 1.34 | 1.15 | About ¥10.63 million | About ¥86.28 million |
| E | 1.34 | 1.46 | About ¥17.2 million | About ¥109.38 million |
Cases A and C differ by about ¥8.75 million in ten-year cumulative cash flow. For the same property and the same loan, being able to raise rents 2% a year leaves about 1.8 times as much cash in hand. Valuing year-10 NOI at the same 5.76% NOI yield as at purchase gives about ¥88.14 million in Case A, roughly ¥11.86 million below the ¥100 million purchase price, and about ¥119.52 million in Case C, roughly ¥19.52 million above it. The loan balance after ten years is about ¥53.82 million, so the valuation gap becomes a gap in equity. The valuation yield at sale will vary with market conditions, so this model does not assume the same 5.76% will apply.
How many units can be repriced
To apply the simulation to real operations, count how many chances you have to adjust rents. The main ones are:
- Tenant turnover: when a unit is re-let after move-out, the rent can be set against current comparable rents nearby.
- Lease renewal: rent can be negotiated at renewal, but the tenant must agree.
- Rent increase request: Article 32 of the Land and Building Lease Act allows a request for a future increase when rent has become unreasonable because of economic changes. A request alone does not settle the increase, and negotiation with the tenant comes first.
Asking rents are set against comparable rents at the time, so buildings with frequent turnover follow the market more easily, while buildings with long-staying tenants tend to see rents stay put. Laying out the rent roll (rent schedule) with move-in year, current rent and nearby asking rent in three columns puts a number on how much each unit's rent could rise if it turns over.
Separating costs that are hard to move
Splitting operating costs into those that move with rent and those that do not makes the effect of rising prices easier to read.
| Type | Item | Amount in this model | Relation to rent |
|---|---|---|---|
| Moves with rent | Management fee | ¥400,000 | 5% of rent, so it rises with rent |
| Moves with rent | Repairs and restoration | ¥640,000 | Set at 8% of rent, but in practice depends on construction costs |
| Independent of rent | Property tax | ¥600,000 | Set by revaluation and tax rates |
| Independent of rent | Common-area utilities and cleaning | ¥400,000 | Depends on tariffs and contractor labor costs |
| Independent of rent | Insurance | ¥200,000 | Depends on premium revisions |
Items independent of rent total ¥1.2 million, 53.6% of operating costs. There is limited room to negotiate these down yourself, so routine practices such as re-quoting regularly, comparing management and cleaning contractors, and getting several quotes at insurance renewal show up in the numbers.
Checklist before and after purchase
Check the movement of costs and rents under rising prices in this order:
- Line up three years of actual operating costs (property tax notices, utility bills, insurance premiums, repair invoices) and compute the average annual growth rate
- On the rent roll, list move-in year, current rent and nearby comparable rent to identify how many units can be repriced and when
- From debt service and NOI over the holding period, calculate DSCR year by year through year 10
- Confirm that DSCR stays above your bank's or your own minimum even if rent growth is half of what you expect (close to Cases A and D here)
- Re-quote repairs and insurance once a year and look for savings on the same terms
Price movements themselves cannot be forecast, but whether loan payments can still be met under the bad combination of flat rents and rising costs can be checked in a spreadsheet before purchase.
Frequently Asked Questions
QWhat happens to rental profit in Japan if rents stay flat and operating costs rise 3% a year?
In this model, a 12-unit RC building with ¥8 million in annual rent and ¥2.24 million in operating costs starts with NOI of ¥5.76 million. With flat rents and 3% annual cost growth, year-10 NOI falls to ¥5.077 million, down 11.9%. DSCR against the ¥4.307 million annual debt service drops from 1.34 to 1.18.
QHow much must rents rise each year to offset 3% annual cost growth in a Japanese rental property?
In this model, raising rents 1% a year against 3% annual cost growth leaves year-10 NOI at ¥5.827 million, close to the year-1 figure of ¥5.76 million. Because operating costs are under 30% of rent, rent growth below cost growth can still offset it.
QWhat is DSCR for a rental property in Japan, and what level is a reasonable target?
DSCR (debt service coverage ratio) is NOI divided by annual principal-and-interest payments; below 1.0, income cannot cover the loan payments. In this model, even a fall from 1.34 to 1.18 leaves less cushion if vacancy or unexpected repairs follow. Acceptable levels vary by lender.
QCan a landlord in Japan raise rent for existing tenants?
Rent for existing tenants changes by agreement or through a rent adjustment request under Article 32 of the Land and Building Lease Act. If rent has become unreasonable because of economic changes, an increase can be requested going forward, but it does not take effect automatically and negotiation comes first.
QWhat should a landlord in Japan check first when prices are rising?
Check three years of actual fixed costs that do not move with rent (property tax, common-area utilities, insurance) and how many units can be repriced at renewal or turnover. In this model, the faster fixed costs rise relative to rent, the more NOI erodes.
Sources
Talk to us even if you don't know where to start
Buying, selling, financing, property management and inheritance planning. Practitioners will propose an approach tailored to your situation.






Comments
Comment guidelinesMembers can comment on this article. Every comment is checked by AI before it is published.
Sign in to comment